Did Not Make The Cut #4

The Code is Good.
Description

This one is a classic “nothing bad could possibly happen” scenario.

A lead casually drops a “quick review” request into the void—complete with the reassuring phrase: “the code is good.”
Two seasoned developers immediately recognize the danger and choose the safest possible response: silence and emotional detachment.

Unfortunately… Pete still believes in teamwork.

One approval later, the build is broken, QA is yelling into the development channel, and the original author has mysteriously “gone home.”

Pete is now the proud new owner of a problem he didn't create, doesn't understand, and definitely didn't mean to approve.

The Code is Good.

Quick Code Review 1
Quick Code Review 2
Quick Code Review 3
Developer Channel
Lee (Lead): Dropping a small PR. The code is good. I just need a quick 👍 so I can merge.
Glenn: Define “small.”
Lee (Lead): Only touched like… 14 files.
Rob: That's not small. That's a lifestyle change..
Pete: Looks straightforward to me. Approving now.
Pete: done. 👍
Lee goes offline

Glenn: Pete No ...
2 minutes later

CI Bot: ❌ Build failed
CI Bot: ❌ Tests failed: 37
Quinn (QA): Who's fixing this?
Rob: Lee?
Glenn: Lee went offline 5 minutes ago.
Quinn (QA): … Pete?
Pete: ... I guess I will take a look, a long look.
Lesson Learned

- “Quick review” is never quick.
- “The code is good” is not a test plan.
- Silence from senior devs is not confusion—it's survival.
- If someone disappears right after a merge… that's not a coincidence.

And most importantly:
If you didn't write it, don't trust it—especially when someone tells you to.

← Previous
The Blog
Next →